With reference to the conventional constitutional classification of Indian…

2023

With reference to the conventional constitutional classification of Indian federalism, which of the following statements gives the accepted description?

Answer: A. ‘A Quasi Federal State’ is the result of Indian Federalism in the country.ConceptFederalism divides constitutional authority between different levels of government. Vertical power-sharing concerns the distribution of authority among…

  1. A.

    ‘A Quasi Federal State’ is the result of Indian Federalism in the country.

  2. B.

    Indian Federalism sets up a single polity in the country.

  3. C.

    Indian Federalism is not horizontal with strong unitary base.

  4. D.

    More than one of the above

  5. E.

    None of the above

Attempted by 19 students.

Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: A

Concept

Federalism divides constitutional authority between different levels of government. Vertical power-sharing concerns the distribution of authority among levels, while horizontal power-sharing concerns its distribution among organs such as the legislature, executive and judiciary. A federal arrangement may still give the central level comparatively stronger powers; the conventional label for that combination is quasi-federal or federal with a unitary bias.

Application

India has Union and State governments with constitutionally assigned legislative fields under Articles 245–246 and the Seventh Schedule. At the same time, residuary, emergency and coordinating powers give the Union a pronounced central advantage. Under the conventional classification requested by the stem, this combination is described as ‘a quasi-federal State’.

Contrast

  • ‘A quasi-federal State’ names the recognized combination of federal division and a comparatively stronger Union.

  • ‘A single polity’ describes one integrated political community, but it does not state the constitutional distribution of authority between the Union and the States.

  • ‘Not horizontal with strong unitary base’ mixes the horizontal-versus-vertical power-sharing axis with the separate issue of relative Union strength; it is not itself the conventional constitutional classification requested.

  • ‘More than one of the above’ would require at least two substantive statements to give the accepted conventional classification; only the quasi-federal description does so.

  • ‘None of the above’ would require every substantive statement to miss the accepted classification; the quasi-federal description is present.

Cross-check

The BPSC 2023 Set A official answer key marks question 107 as A. That official key agrees with the constitutional structure: divided Union–State fields coexist with a strong central tilt.

Result

Result: ‘A quasi-federal State’ is the accepted description.

Explore the full course: Uptet Paper 2

Loading lesson…