Which of the following basic values was accepted by all leaders much before…
2023
Which of the following basic values was accepted by all leaders much before the Constituent Assembly met to deliberate on the Constitution of India?
Answer: D. More than one of the above — ConceptConstitution-making often codifies a political consensus that already exists; it does not create every public value from nothing. Before India’s…
- A.
The Universal Adult Franchise
- B.
The Right of Freedom and Equality
- C.
The Protection of Rights of Minorities
- D.
More than one of the above
- E.
None of the above
Attempted by 30 students.
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: D
Concept
Constitution-making often codifies a political consensus that already exists; it does not create every public value from nothing.
Before India’s Constituent Assembly began formal deliberations, the national movement had already produced broad agreement on representative participation, civil freedom and equality, and safeguards for minorities.
Application
Each of the three substantive values listed in the question belongs to that prior consensus: universal adult franchise expresses equal political participation; freedom and equality express equal civil status; and protection of minority rights safeguards diversity within democracy.
Contrast
Universal adult franchise gives adult citizens the vote without property, education, caste, or sex qualifications.
Freedom and equality establish civil liberty and equal civic standing.
Protection of minority rights prevents majority rule from erasing minority interests and identities.
“More than one of the above” applies because more than one listed substantive value—and in fact all three—had prior acceptance.
“None of the above” would require every listed substantive value to lack prior acceptance, which conflicts with that historical consensus.
Cross-check and result
Cross-checking the three substantive choices against the national movement’s constitutional consensus confirms all three; therefore the answer by value is “More than one of the above.”