Which logical informal fallacy is committed in the following argument: 'Mr. X…

2022

Which logical informal fallacy is committed in the following argument: 'Mr. X used abusive language toward the child who threw a stone at his car. Since child abuse is a crime, he should be reported to the authorities'?

Answer: C. EquivocationConceptEquivocation occurs when a key word or phrase changes meaning between premises, making an inference appear valid even though the meanings differ. It is…

  1. A.

    Appeal to Emotion

  2. B.

    Hasty generalisation

  3. C.

    Equivocation

  4. D.

    Appeal to force

Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: C

Concept

Equivocation occurs when a key word or phrase changes meaning between premises, making an inference appear valid even though the meanings differ. It is a defect in the use of language rather than evidence for the conclusion.

Application

In the statement about abusive language, “abusive language” means insulting or offensive speech directed at a child. In “child abuse is a crime,” “child abuse” means harmful mistreatment of a child. The argument shifts the sense of “abuse” while treating it as unchanged, so the conclusion does not follow from the premise. The fallacy is Equivocation.

Contrast and cross-check

  • Appeal to Emotion relies on feelings such as pity, fear, or anger as support.

  • Hasty generalisation draws a broad rule from too few or unrepresentative cases.

  • Appeal to force uses a threat or coercion as support.

The repeated expression changes meaning, which cross-checks the classification as Equivocation.

Explore the full course: Nta Ugc Net Paper 1

Loading lesson…