Which of the following is not a fallacy of Ambiguity?
2022
Which of the following is not a fallacy of Ambiguity?
Answer: D. Accident — ConceptFallacies of ambiguity arise when an argument’s wording permits a shift or more than one interpretation that changes the apparent support. The…
- A.
Equivocation
- B.
Amphiboly
- C.
Accent
- D.
Accident
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: D
Concept
Fallacies of ambiguity arise when an argument’s wording permits a shift or more than one interpretation that changes the apparent support. The ambiguity may be lexical, grammatical, or caused by emphasis.
Application
Accident concerns the misapplication of a general rule to an exceptional case, so its mechanism is rule-exception handling rather than an ambiguous expression. Therefore, the value that is not a fallacy of ambiguity is Accident.
Contrast
Equivocation shifts the meaning of a word or phrase between parts of an argument.
Amphiboly permits more than one reading because of a sentence’s grammatical structure.
Accent changes the force of an expression through emphasis or quotation context.
Result: Accident is the required value.