When inference is based not on causation but on uniformity of co-existence,…
2022
When inference is based not on causation but on uniformity of co-existence, what is it called as per Classical Indian School of Logic?
Answer: B. Samanyatodrsta — ConceptIn Nyāya, inference (anumāna) is classified according to the relation by which an unperceived fact is known from a perceived sign. One traditional…
- A.
Kevalanvayi
- B.
Samanyatodrsta
- C.
Purvavat
- D.
Sesavat
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: B
Concept
In Nyāya, inference (anumāna) is classified according to the relation by which an unperceived fact is known from a perceived sign. One traditional threefold division distinguishes inference from cause to effect, effect to cause, and a non-causal relation established through uniform co-existence.
Application
The stem explicitly excludes a causal relation and instead describes a regular co-existence. That description is the defining basis of sāmānyatodṛṣṭa inference.
Contrast
Kevalānvayi concerns a different classification: its universal relation is established through affirmative instances only.
Sāmānyatodṛṣṭa rests on a generally observed uniform co-existence rather than a cause–effect sequence.
Pūrvavat proceeds from a known cause to an unperceived effect, such as anticipating rain from cloud conditions.
Śeṣavat proceeds from an observed effect to its preceding cause, such as inferring earlier rain from a swollen river.
Therefore, the inference described in the question is sāmānyatodṛṣṭa.